Mark each person Y or N against the 10 criteria. Ten taps each. Then the whole team lands on one grid, so you can see the gaps that run across everybody, not just the ones in front of you.
Mark Y or N against each criterion. More Y and they're the ones. More N and it's cull or cultivate.
Each column is one of the 10 criteria. The bar under a column is how much of your team clears it, which is a finding about the business rather than about any one person.